Focus on bank tactics for denying loan modifications

I’m letting this great article from Reuters run longer than the usual, as it is a pitch perfect collection of real life examples of what is happening thousands of times a day across the country.

If you have ever sought to work directly with your lender for a loan modification, see how many of the experiences below match your own.

Don’t be surprised if you  lose count!

Shirley Burnell, from Oakland, California, has been trying to get her loan restructured since 2007

She never missed a payment, but the adjustable rate mortgage she got in 2004 shot up to a monthly payment she could no longer afford.

First she provided documents without getting any response, then she was denied in April by her servicer, Bank of America for not providing documents it never actually asked for.

As one part of the bank appealed that decision and approved her for a trial modification, another part denied her again – twice – providing two new reasons in part based on inaccurate calculations, according to documents reviewed by Reuters.

When asked about Burnell’s case, a bank spokesman said she was unable to qualify under “imminent default provisions,” a third reason that Burnell said she had never been given.

At one point, Burnell even received notice the bank would accelerate foreclosure proceedings, despite her perfect payment record and the letter itself saying the bank owed her $281.01.

“They gave you a funky loan in the first place, and now they’re refusing to work with people to get it worked out,” Burnell said. “It just keeps you upset all the time.”

But servicers have dragged their feet on providing wide-scale modifications. They continue to lose documents, use inaccurate numbers to issue denials, or both approve and deny applications at the same time, according to housing advocates.

“If you get a minor traffic ticket, you get a right to an impartial hearing, but if you are applying for federal home saving assistance, the bank is judge, jury, and executioner,” said Joseph Sant, a lawyer at Staten Island Legal Services who helps defend homeowners facing foreclosure.

‘GOING IN CIRCLES’

It took nearly one year for Hakan Tale to convince his servicer, Chase, that it overvalued his house by more than $100,000 in rejecting a modification.

Once he was able to convince Chase of that mistake, it rejected him again, dropping his monthly income by almost $4,000 and determining he didn’t make enough money to qualify, even though his actual income had not changed.

In November, more than two years after Tale first sought a modification, Chase asked him to submit an entirely new application.

“Maybe they don’t want me to be an example for other people,” said Tale, who lives with his wife and three children in Staten Island, New York.

Another Staten Island resident, 77-year-old Hamson McPherson, was first denied a modification two years ago by his servicer, Wells Fargo, after it miscalculated his income.

The bank then served him with a foreclosure summons and complaint, which in New York can lead to court-supervised settlement conference. But it stalled on moving forward for so long that McPherson triggered the proceedings himself in August 2011 to try to negotiate an alternative to foreclosure.

In October, more than two years after he first applied for a modification, the bank told him there was an investor restriction on the loan, which meant it couldn’t modify it.

That investor agreement was public, Wells Fargo told him.

But after confronting the bank with that agreement, which did not include any such restriction, the bank told him there was a previously undisclosed secret document that included the restriction.

“It’s a nightmare,” McPherson said, “when you have these things, you don’t get proper sleep at all.”

In an ironic twist, the hold music played when he called Wells Fargo once was a song called, “Going in Circles.”

“I listened to it for five minutes and then hung up because I was so upset,” he said.

A Wells Fargo spokesman said the bank has “worked for some time to find payment assistance within the investor guidelines of the loan.”

“We continue to work with him to find alternatives to foreclosure,” the spokesman said.

‘NOT DOING THEIR JOB‘

Even with staff additions — Chase, for example, added some 10,000 employees to deal with defaults, and Bank of America increased its 5,000 employees to 40,000 — individual negotiators can still have hundreds, or even thousands of cases open, according to housing advocates.

Employees can be so overwhelmed that applications languish for months. Banks consider financial documents “stale” within two or three months, forcing homeowners to provide updated documents all over again.

“These are institutions that have taken a huge amount of bailout money. There should be a level of responsibility to communities,” said Josh Zinner, an advocate with the Neighborhood Economic Development Advocacy Project in New York. “HAMP is far from perfect, but the biggest problem is servicers not doing their job.”

Loan modification cancellations way up; Feds whitewash problem

The numbers of the following report are really dismal when compared to the government’s projections of the impact of the HAMP program. It is true that the banks will have to experience more “pressure” before they do the right thing.

Problem is, the Feds think that publishing a report and holding back a few payments, courtesy of the tax payers, will do the trick. Laughable.

If you don’t want your loan modification to go from a “trial” to a cancellation, the best bet by far is to retain an A rated, experienced attorney with plenty of testimonials.

Number Of Homeowners In Loan Modification Program Rises In October

Steven and Lisa Maultsby outside the home they lost to foreclosure while awaiting a loan modification.

WASHINGTON -(Dow Jones)- An Obama administration program designed to prevent foreclosures gave struggling homeowners a little more relief.

Treasury Department statistics released Wednesday showed the Home Affordable Modification program helped 735,464 U.S. homeowners avoid losing their homes through permanent loan modifications as of October.

That number was up from the figure of 720,612 for September that was reported a month ago.

While reflecting improvement, the number is well below the initial program goal of helping 3 million to 4 million borrowers.

HAMP was designed to assist homeowners suffering after the housing bubble burst. Lenders get incentives to help borrowers avoid foreclosure by reducing their mortgage payments.

The data Wednesday showed 883,076 permanent loan modifications had been started since the program began in 2009. But 147,612 were canceled–an increase of 11, 250 from September.

Included in the report Wednesday on the housing market were assessments for the 10 largest mortgage servicers participating in the Making Home Affordable Progam.

“The mortgage servicing industry lacked accountability and transparency when this crisis started,” said Treasury’s Assistant Secretary for Financial Stability Tim Massad. …we will keep this up so that the industry continues to change its ways.”

Homeowners often make trial payments before a loan modification can become permanent, and some people have had their modifications canceled.

Bank of America caught running widow out of her home – illegally

This is what happens when banks believe they are beyond the reach of the law. Unfortunately, the Bank of America gets away with this kind of behavior all the time — and often, it goes completely unnoticed.

PHOENIX    June Geffre lost her husband Tom to pancreatic cancer in November 2009. Months before he died, he applied for the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP). Geffre said  a permanent modification was granted shortly after he passed away – but she’s run into all sorts of problems because her dead husband never got to sign the papers.

“Here I was, paying every month (the amount the bank told me to pay), thinking I was OK and waiting for the OK that the loan would be approved in my name and everything,” said Geffre. “Then they hit me in July saying, ‘We can’t accept your money anymore.'” 

She said bank representatives told her she was paying the wrong amount and was now in default. She was at her wit’s end when ASU’s Homeowner Advocacy Unit and other community agencies stepped in to help.

“Ms. Geffre sent at least five copies of the death certificate.  It took that long for Bank of America to realize her husband was dead,” said Alyson Vivattanapa, a student attorney with the Homeowner Advocacy Unit.

A foreclosure sale was scheduled for 10 a.m. Tuesday.

“Federal law allows her to assume the mortgage so she can stay in her home,” said Vivattanapa.

Advocates got a temporary restraining order just in time, which will keep June in her home for another month while they hash this out in court.

“There’s absolutely a great injustice,” said Vivattanapa. “Bank of America should have accepted the HAMP agreement and let her stay in home.”

“I don’t have a whole heck of a lot, but what I do have I worked hard for,” said Geffre. “What right do they have to do this to anybody?”

CBS 5 News contacted Bank of America for comment.  A spokesperson responded via email, saying, “We are unable to comment on this case due to the pending litigation.”

Both sides are due back in court later this week.

Judge to Bank of America Lawyer: “You are telling lies.”

In a perfect world, homeowners would request loan modifications from their lenders, and the qualified individuals would get their fair share of the bailout money that the feds lavished on the banks.

In this real world example, a decorated public servant with a legitimate hardship gets pummeled by his lender until the disgrace catches the eye of a decent judge just before the man is unlawfully forced from his home.

Bank Excuses on Foreclosure Growing Stale

The Bank of America lawyer laid down a patented rhetorical move heard in courts across America. Your Honor, this Orange County, N.Y., homeowner — a New York City police officer — didn’t make enough money to qualify for a mortgage modification. He didn’t send us the right documents.

He didn’t, he didn’t, he didn’t, and so we should be allowed to foreclose.

Justice Catherine M. Bartlett of New York State Supreme Court cut off the lawyer. You, she said, are telling me lies.

“Bank of America got a bailout, and this is an outrage, how this man has been treated,” she said. “Hard-working, middle-class Americans are trying to make it, trying to modify with your bank.”

Either bank officials show up in person, the justice said, or I’m going to order them “here in handcuffs.”

Wouldn’t the nation benefit from knowing the truth about the behavior of banks and bankers?

The cultural dial seems to be turning now.

Back in Orange County, the Legal Services lawyer Gina DeCrescenzo had fought for years to protect that New York police officer, William Castillo, filing motion after motion. No judge seemed to share her frustration until October, when Justice Bartlett threw out the foreclosure.

“You want to appeal me, you go right ahead,” the judge told the bank lawyer. “Because what happened here is disgusting.”

Successful loan modification: Running to the Government vs. Understanding Incentives

Here’s my letter to The Philadelphia Inquirer:

You report that three federal agencies have launched efforts to stop scam loan modification companies. (Mortgage Help Scams Still a Big Problem.)

You go on to say, “Their advice, which we’ve seen before, is worth repeating.”

Before getting to that advice, I have to ask: Really? The best place to seek advice if I am a homeowner with a hardship, a house that’s underwater and/or a high interest rate is the federal government?

When you urge homeowners to run to the safety of the Inspector General for TARP, you side against the many States Attorneys who have decided to go around the feds and sue the big banks for unlawful acts against homeowners seeking a loan mods.

Now to your first bit of advice: “First, you can apply for the federal Home Affordable Modification Program, on your own or with help from a HUD-approved housing counselor for free.” The problem is that the lenders do not want to participate in this program, and have proven to be bad actors, going through the motions of providing loan mods with no intention of doing so.

The states want to prosecute and show homeowners the misconduct of their lenders; the feds want to take a few buckets of hush money from the banks and continue the charade of “helping” homeowners via non-profit councilors who are government workers paid for by the banks.

If all the HUD -approved councilors in the nation teamed up for one loan modification, the lender would still have no incentive to grant it.

Since the government spent 75 billion dollars on its Making Home Affordable program, foreclosures have skyrocketed. 650,000 borrowers have enrolled in the program, and  only 2000 have received a loan modification. Those numbers add up to an abject failure.

Then you say: “Only your mortgage servicer can grant a loan modification. No third-party can do so. Beware of anyone seeking to charge you in advance for mortgage modification services. In most cases, charging fees in advance for a mortgage modification is illegal.” Of course only the servicer can grant a modification. That is precisely why you need a third party, a legal representative, to force the servicer to grant the loan mod.

A loan mod attorney essentially motivates the lender to do the right thing by threatening to spotlight previous foul-play. Suddenly, it’s in the lenders best interest to modify the loan and make the home affordable.

Yes, it is illegal to charge in advance for a modification, but that does not mean, as you apparently believe, that no payment should be made. Any serious loan mod attorney will provide a full debt-to-income analysis and loan review before requesting a retainer. And all retainers should be placed in escrow while the modification proceeds.

The tenor of all your advice suggests that you fail to see the insight of Ronald Reagan’s timeless quip about the nine words every citizen fears the most. In case you missed it: “I’m from the government and I’m here to help.”

Sincerely,

Kurt Linn

Bank of America accused of breaking the law — again

This law suit against the lending practices of The Bank of America is significant as it is the first complaint that goes beyond specific instances of deception and lies to call out the bank’s entire loan modification process.

And that is a very good step in the right direction.

Arizona Sues Bank Of America, Alleges Loan Modification Fraud

PHOENIX — Attorneys general in Arizona and Nevada filed civil lawsuits Friday against Bank of America Corp., alleging that the lender is misleading and deceiving homeowners who have tried to modify mortgages in two of the nation’s most foreclosure-damaged states.

Bank of America violated Arizona’s consumer fraud law by misleading consumers who tried to reduce their monthly payments to keep their homes, state Attorney General Terry Goddard said. The bank also violated the terms of a 2009 consent agreement requiring its Countrywide mortgage subsidiary to implement a loan modification program, the Arizona lawsuit alleges.

Hundreds of homeowners kept making their mortgage payments because Bank of America repeatedly assured them that their loans were being modified, Goddard said. Instead, many lost their homes anyway.

“Those people could have used that money for something else,” Goddard told The Associated Press. “They were deceived into continuing to make mortgage payments when they had no hope of saving their homes.”

Nevada Attorney General Catherine Cortez Masto told the AP that the Silver State’s lawsuit was a last resort to try to get the bank to change its ways. It was filed after several discussions with bank managers led to assurances but little more.

“Clearly there is a disconnect between what Bank of America tells me at the management level and what’s happening on the front line,” Masto said.

Masto said separate lawsuits show the bank’s problems with consumers are widespread.

“The only thing that I’m asking is that (Bank of America) give them a reasonable response in a timely manner,” she said. “It is, in my perspective, a callous disregard for what we are telling them.”

The Arizona attorney general’s office was deluged with consumer complaints and launched an investigation more than a year ago, Goddard said. Settlement talks with Bank of America began in April but ultimately collapsed Thursday.

The Arizona lawsuit, filed in Maricopa County Superior Court, alleges that the bank has repeatedly violated an October 2008 consent agreement between Bank of America and 11 states requiring the bank’s Countrywide subsidiary to modify hundreds of thousands of loans. Arizona’s agreement was finalized in 2009.

Countrywide was accused of engaging in widespread deceptive practices with its customers, and Bank of America agreed to reduce principal or interest payments by up to $8.4 billion on those loans.

“Nobody’s got a great record, but Bank of America’s is worse than any of them.

Nevada’s complaint accuses the bank of operating its loan modification program in violation of the Nevada Deceptive Trade Practices Act. It seeks civil penalties and restitution along with other fees.

“My bank said they’re willing to help me!” Yea, right

Massachusetts Sues 5 Major Banks Over Foreclosure Practices

The rampant criminality of the big banks regarding loan modifications and foreclosures is finally being put into the spotlight, thanks to a few serious state’s attorneys.

In addition to shining a light on what the banks have been up to ever since they were bailed out by the tax payers, the states are also shaming the Feds by speaking out on violations and deception about which the regulators have remained silent.

Shame on you, feds.

Martha Coakley, with her staff in Boston, accused lenders of “deceptive and unlawful conduct.”

Citing extensive abuses of troubled borrowers across Massachusetts, the state’s attorney general sued the nation’s five largest mortgage lenders on Thursday, seeking relief for consumers hurt by what she called unfair and deceptive business practices.

The attorney general, Martha Coakley, and her investigators contend that the banks improperly foreclosed on troubled borrowers by relying on fraudulent legal documentation or by failing to modify loans for homeowners after promising to do so. The suit also contends that the banks’ use of MERS “corrupted” the state’s public land recording system by not registering legal transfers properly.

“There is no question that the deceptive and unlawful conduct by Wall Street and the large banks played a central role in this crisis through predatory lending and securitization of those loans,” Ms. Coakley said at a news conference announcing the lawsuit. “The banks may think they are too big to fail or too big to care about the impact of their actions, but we believe they are not too big to have to obey the law.”

Officials at all of the banks issued statements saying they would fight the suit.

How do the bankers respond? By pretending to care about the very homeowners whom they’ve been victimizing, of course.

Vickee Adams of Wells Fargo said, “Regrettably, the action announced in Massachusetts today will do little to help Massachusetts homeowners or the recovery of the housing economy in the Commonwealth.”

“So far the servicers have escaped any real review or punishment for their bad practices because federal regulators have by and large given them a pass on whether they followed the law in foreclosures,” Mr. Eggert said. “This lawsuit argues that they haven’t followed the law and that they can’t just fix all their problems after the fact.”

Among the misconduct cited in the Massachusetts complaint were 14 cases of foreclosures by institutions that had not shown proof that they had the legal right to seize the underlying properties when they did so. All the banks also deceived troubled borrowers, the complaint said, about the loan modification process.

“If the state can go forward and do real discovery, it will be the first time that anyone has really dug into the servicers’ files to see what they have done,” he added. “The feds conducted an investigation where they looked at very few files, and here the state could demand to see a lot.”

 It boggles the mind that the the Feds have given the banks a pass from the time they gave them 156  billion dollars in tax payer cash to the present day.

A cautionary tale for do-it-yourselfers

If it’s one thing that research shows time and again in all walks of personal finance it’s this: doing it yourself sounds great in theory, but in real life, it ends up very messy.

In the case of loan mods, it’s not simply that individuals face a big learning curve, but more importantly, they face lenders who wish then ill.

Homeowners Seeking “Making Home Affordable” Loan Modifications Frustrated By Inefficiency

Last week, we profiled one couple’s fight to save their home from foreclosure, and asked you to share your experiences with the Obama Administration’s “homeowners’ bailout,” Making Home Affordable.

An overwhelming number of you wrote in to tell us about your experience negotiating a government loan modification. Those of you who responded had one major complaint about the Making Home Affordable program: that the process of dealing with banks and loan servicers is inefficient, frustrating and difficult to navigate. Those who eventually did receive a Home Affordable Modification often had waited for months. Our respondents cited lost paperwork, miscommunications and delays as some of the difficulties they faced in the loan modification process.

Part of the problem is that banks are hard-pressed to keep up with the sheer volume of borrowers having mortgage troubles. According to a Treasury Department press release (PDF) from May, Chase fields 8,000 to 10,000 calls about the MHA

Megan McCord claims that when she first contacted her bank about a Making Home Affordable loan modification, they didn’t have a system in place to work with the Obama program.

Thinking of selling your home to recover? Think again

Lenders often try to push homeowners with hardships into short sales. Given recent statistics on home values, that’s a losing proposition.

As Home Prices Sink, Home Ownership Heads to New Lows

Home prices across the nation are now right back where they were at the beginning of 2003. All that was gained is largely now lost, and the effect on home ownership could continue for decades.

“Consumer attitudes have gotten a lot more negative about long-term commitment,” said Standard and Poors’ David Blitzer .”They dropped to new lows. This takes them below the point we saw in 2009, where briefly we all thought this thing was about to turn around.”

And that’s the problem.

Every time we think things are turning around in the housing market, we get hit with some new problem, like last year’s so-called “robo-signing” foreclosure paperwork scandal, which managed to stall the cleansing of distress in the market for over a year. Now that foreclosures are ramping up again, prices are coming down again.

All this could push home ownership down to levels not seen at least since before the Census began tracking this data in 1963.

As home prices refuse to stabilize, and in fact continue to fall, negative equity will only increase. The vast majority of the ten plus million people who are underwater are still paying their mortgages, but they are deeply underwater, 30 percent and higher. That will take a long time to correct, and will stagnate much of the market for years to come, as these owners are unable to sell.

Member of Congress faces “bankers’ runaround”

No matter what your political persuasion, this video makes it clear that the banks have very little interest in providing the services necessary for modifying home loans.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free